Algeria Gate: An illegal administrative decision can have heavy financial consequences for the state. On September 24, 2026, the Administrative Court of Melun ordered the administration to pay more than €33,500 to an Algerian national after the illegal refusal of her residence certificate.
The case dates back to August 30, 2021. The Prefecture of Seine-et-Marne had refused to renew this Algerian woman’s residence certificate bearing the mention “private and family life.” This decision was accompanied by an obligation to leave French territory (OQTF) within thirty days.
The Algerian national challenged this measure in court. In 2023, the Administrative Court of Appeal finally annulled the prefectural refusal, thereby recognizing the illegality of the decision taken against her.
But the annulment was not enough to repair the consequences suffered during this period. The applicant therefore initiated a new procedure to obtain compensation for the damages caused by the refusal of residence.
The Administrative Court of Melun ruled in her favor and ordered the state to pay her more than €33,500.
This case recalls that an illegal prefectural decision concerning the residence of a foreigner can not only be annulled by the courts, but can also give rise to a right to compensation when the person concerned demonstrates the existence of damage directly linked to that decision.








